The origin and nature of the object in the theories of klein and fairbairn12 stephen a. Aggression is common in splitting as fear of the bad object causes a destructive. Melanie klein 19461986, from the british object relations school, employed the term both to refer to the splitting mechanism used by the infant to organize his or her experience and to. The origin and nature of the object in the theories of klein. Since homophobia is one of the most destructive forces active in the world today, kleinian theory can be of. Splitting is essentially an attempt to create order out of chaos. Splitting and projective identification in clinical lectures on klein.
His unusual cooperativeness and insight allowed me to gather a wealth of material within a few months, and made it possible to present a consecutive daybyday account of an analysis without making the book too long. Melanie klein was a great psychotherapist who teaches us how to stop either idealising or denigrating others. The present paper starts from the reflection that there is a curious phenomenological gap in psychoanalysis when it comes to processes of splitting and to describing the life of psychic fragments resulting from processes of splitting. One, annotated and transcribed by janet sayers and published in 20, brings together 10 typed fragments from kleins archive. Quantitative process analysis of psychoanalytic psychotherapy for patient g revealed two factors, which were produced by the pfactor analysis of the 17 defense mechanisms on the cadm. Splitting and protective identification michael feldman the way in which the concepts of splitting and projective identification have evolved in melanie klein s work illustrates very well, i think, the creative interaction between theory and clinical observation, which runs through psychoanalysis.
In 1903, she married arthur klein and relocated to budapest. Melanie kleins theory all infants split splitting is looking at an object as either all good or all bad based upon the present experience of that object 1st object is the breast later generalized to the mother if the breast is full of yummy milk providing pleasure to the. She used observation of children at play with selected toys her play technique as a substitute for the adult free association. She used observation of children at play with selected toys her play technique as.
Melanie kleins theory all infants split splitting is looking at an object as either all good or all bad based upon the present experience of that object 1st object is the breast later generalized to the mother if the breast is full of yummy milk providing pleasure to the child. Klein suggested that preverbal existential anxiety in infancy catalyzed the formation of the unconscious, resulting in the unconscious splitting of the world into good and. Melanie klein was an austrian psychoanalyst who devised therapeutic techniques for children that had great impact on present methods of child care and rearing. Klein has the view that infants suffer a great deal of anxiety and that this is caused by the death instinct within, by the trauma experienced at birth and by experiences of hunger and frustration. The origin and nature of the object in the theories of. One of my main points was the suggestion that in the first few months of life anxiety is predominantly experienced as fear of persecution and that this contributes to certain mechanisms and defenses which characterize the paranoid and schizoid positions. Pdf an analysis of melanie kleins the psychoanalysis of.
Kernberg jacques lacan cornelius castoriadis donald meltzer melanie klein was born on march 30, 1882, in vienna, austria. Envy and gratitude and other works melanie klein download. Klein describes conflicting forces within the psyche, detailing how they interact with equally conflicting external forces, producing a mental structure understood in terms of relationships. Grotstein, you will obtain the most effective point to obtain. Jan 16, 2015 melanie klein was a great psychotherapist who teaches us how to stop either idealising or denigrating others.
Klein, is among those critical of the papers assertions. Object relations theory melanie klein learning theories. A model of human psyche, transitioning from a paranoidschizoid to a depressive position, while emphasizing the critical role of parental care during infancy. Melanie klein and then by some postkleinian authors, in particular donald. Melanie klein object relations theory simply psychology. Learning theories summaries on the learning theories. Splitting the mind within the individual, nation and economy. Mar 26, 2020 melanie klein, austrianborn british psychoanalyst known for her work with young children, in which observations of free play provided insights into the childs unconscious fantasy life, enabling her to psychoanalyze children as young as two or three years of age. She was an innovator on theories and techniques for working with children, such as play therapy and object relations theory. Moriz reisez, was undoubtedly an inspiration to young melanie. Although profoundly rooted in sigmund freuds thinking, melanie klein. She was the primary figure in the development of object relations theory. She originally intended to attend medical school to study psychiatry like her father, but instead married at the age of. On november 24th, klein writes to heimann, asking her to resign as trustee of the newly established melanie klein trust.
Breast, goodbad object the primitive ego cannot perceive or conceive of the objects in its external world as whole, multifaceted persons. Splitting is a part of ordinary life as well as an aspect of schizophrenia. Object relations theory is composed of the diverse and sometimes conflicting ideas of various theorists, mainly melanie klein, ronald fairbairn, and donald winnicott. I will also illustrate how parts of the paranoidschizoid position are conveyed through ridley scotts film, alien 1979. Through this essay, i am going to discuss melanie kleins theory of the paranoidschizoid position, referring to some of the defence mechanisms which the infant uses.
Melanie klein took psychoanalytic thinking in a new direction by recognising the importance of our earliest childhood experiences in the formation of our adult emotional world. Instead it lives in a world of onedimensional objects that have either good or bad intentions towards the infant klein, 1932. Her unabashed disagreements with freudian theory and revolutionary way of thinking was especially important in the development of child analysis. Melanie klein and object relations theory melanie klein 1882 1960 has had a major impact on the development of psychoanalytic thought since freud. Melanie reizes klein 18821960 austrianbritish psychoanalyst 12 keywords. Melanie klein was born into a middleclass jewish family in vienna in 1882.
Psychoanalytical societ y in 1919 and was it s president in the 1920s and 1930s. Melanie klein 18821960 started from freud but developed her own approach. But a careful reader of klein comes away with an impression that she was never overly concerned with contradictions and inconsistencies in the models she was creating. Splitting in normal and pathological populations from. In doing so, she was opposed by anna freud, which split the british psychoanalytical society into separate camps. Process development and identification of segments for patient g.
Melanie kleins ideas in contemporary psychoanalytic practice. Melanie klein acknowledgements my thanks are first and foremost due to my patient. A critical evaluation of the object relations theories of melanie klein and donald winnicott. Notes on some schizoid mechanisms society for psychoanalytic. Splitting, projection, and introjection are psychological mechanisms that characterize many social processes. Pdf an analysis of melanie kleins the psychoanalysis of children. Melanie klein was a gifted clinician, and arrived at a number of extraordinarily useful clinical observations about deeply unconscious processes. Splitting also called blackandwhite thinking or allornothing thinking is the failure in a persons thinking to bring together the dichotomy of both positive and negative qualities of the self and others into a cohesive, realistic whole. Extending and developing sigmund freuds ideas, klein drew on her analysis of childrens play to formulate new concepts such as the paranoidschizoid position and. I propose to summarize some of the conclusions presented in this paper. She made highly original contributions to the development of object relations theory, but many of her theories remain controversial.
Depressive position according to kleins theory 8, the baby further. Increasing awareness of others as psychologically separate from oneself. In kleins formulation, splitting allows the ego to emerge out of the chaos of the paranoidschizoid position and to order its emotional experiences and sensory impressions. Associated with this specific splitting of the paranoidschizoid position 99 the self is another process which klein labelled projective identification. Repression replaces splitting, denial, and projection as primary defense. Pdf an analysis of melanie kleins the psychoanalysis. These contributions made by melanie klein to psychoanalytic thinking, and.
Melanie kleins unfortunate term is too confusing to be useful, and should be replaced, as far as i am concerned, with the more general and straightforward term of projective processes. As freud has pointed out, the remaining portion of the destructive. My experience of the depressive position and therapeutic symbiosis. Melanie klein was the subject of a 1988 play by nicholas wright, entitled mrs. In the object relations theory of melanie klein, she states that children are born with two primary drives. A note on kohut and klein idealisation, splitting and projective. Kleins theory evolved from, but radically altered freuds psychosexual stages. May 06, 2011 splitting as a mental process thus enables us to makes distinctions. For klein and the postkleinians, on the other hand, splitting is an active defence mechanism. Whether youve loved the book or not, if you give your honest and detailed thoughts then people will find new books that are right for them.
She took over the term schizoid in the sense of it used by scottish psychoanalyst, ronald fairbairn, and combined it with hers to coin a new term. Family, education, and career melanie klein was born in vienna on march 30, 1882. I argue that although melanie kleins work is often engaged when talking of splitting particularly through discussions on identification, projection and projective identification, there are. Melanie klein 1946 also described splitting as a normal developmental process. Her theories on the schizoid defences of splitting and projective identification remain influential in psychoanalytical theory today. These mechanisms and defenses are part of normal development and at the same time form the basis for later schizophrenic illness. Melanie klein 1932 is one of the key figures in psychoanalysis.
Melanie klein was a controversial yet highly influential and powerful member of the british psychoanalytical society for over thirty years. It would be sensible to add a parallel general term introjective processes to describe the same concrete quality of phantasies going into oneself. Splitting can be seen as a developmental stage and as a defence mechanism. With respect to theorisations of psychical splitting, this paper explores the psychical. But her ideas provide useful material when seeing clients, especially for experiential learners. International dictionary of psychoanalysis dictionary. Splitting and protective identification michael feldman the way in which the concepts of splitting and projective identification have evolved in melanie kleins work illustrates very well, i think, the creative interaction between theory and clinical observation, which runs through psychoanalysis. Oct 25, 2018 the present paper starts from the reflection that there is a curious phenomenological gap in psychoanalysis when it comes to processes of splitting and to describing the life of psychic fragments resulting from processes of splitting. Object relations theory freud proposed instincts have four basic characteristics. As a result, by the close of the century four kinds of splitting can be clearly identified, among many other possibilities for postkleinians. Melanie klein and her followers have developed a rich and profound set of descriptions of the internal psychological forces which govem the darker side of the human condition. Outstanding among these defenses is the mechanism of splitting internal and external objects, emotions, and the ego.
Writings of melanie klein 19461963 overwhelm the loving. I show that by orchestrating a dialogue between melanie klein and sandor. Set in london in 1934, the play involves a conflict between melanie klein and her daughter melitta schmideberg, after the death of melanie s son hans klein. All humans struggle throughout their entire lives to. Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders 4th. Melanie klein 1946 described idealisation, not in the context of narcissism, but as part of an early defensive splitting and idealisation in which, in an effort to. Two versions of melanie kleins autobiography are available from the downloads section.
Primal splitting as a basis for emotional and cognitive development. Pdf compression, ocr, web optimization using a watermarked evaluation copy of. Klein describes splitting in the way a child seeks to retain good feelings and introject good objects, whilst expelling bad objects and projecting bad feelings onto an external object, in order to protect the good object from being contaminated by the bad object. The term paranoidschizoid position refers to a constellation of anxieties, defences and internal and external object relations that klein considers to be characteristic of the earliest months of an infants life and to continue to a greater or lesser extent into childhood and adulthood.
The ideas of melanie klein and object relations theory. This link from the melanie klein trust explains the depressive position in more detail. Splittingandprojective identification minnicks klein. One, annotated and transcribed by janet sayers and published in 20, brings together 10 typed fragments from klein s archive. Melanie klein was an austrianborn psychoanalyst who pioneered the development of child psychoanalysis. Klein s theory splitting projective identification. Importance of object relations theories for development of. Her theories about the development of a childs inner world transformed psychoanalysis and have had a deep and farreaching impact.
Slides melanie klein unconscious phantasy major criticisms of kleins ideas. Marking the end of their long and close friendship, heimann leaves the kleinian group. Other readers will always be interested in your opinion of the books youve read. Throughout life, splitting serves this exact function. The paranoid phase seemed to be augmented by states in which the mind and the self were themselves split up and therefore damaged. Many of the major political events, crises, and controversies of our time can only be fully understood if.
Further development towards the depressive position, when the object starts to be experienced as a whole, facilitates the development of mature idealization. This is a precondition of later integration and the basis of the faculty of discrimination the. The chief characteristic of the paranoidschizoid position is the splitting of both self and object into good and bad, with at first little or no integration between them. Last weeks lecture was on the ideas of melanie klein and object relations theory the ideas of melanie klein are not easy and it is difficult to get your head around them. Free pdf splitting and projective identification classical psychoanalysis and its applications, by james s. Melanie kleins theory of the psychogenesis of the self hinges upon. In simpler terms, we are often in a position to lack a precise understanding of what is being split and how the splitting occurs. Two versions of melanie klein s autobiography are available from the downloads section. Many view kleins theory as too speculative and unrealistic with regard to the degree of mental sophistication that she attributed to infants. But of late i have been increasingly able to catch, if i listen attentively, the sound of the sobs which i had the strength to control in my fathers presence, and which broke out only when i found myself alone with mamma.
1312 1636 465 569 580 1632 973 551 459 1573 1448 495 28 1166 1553 1132 65 1163 454 796 830 663 888 1296 299 1090 94 1038 584 1180 1267 198 1101 1010 452 116 824 1185 598 710